Closet Picks

Against the shelf

What kind of cinema

A leaderboard only tells you what is popular. These compare each slice of the collection with how often guests reach into it, so 1.00 means exactly as often as the shelf predicts.

By decade

Decade In collection Picks Reached for Films reached
1920s 24 28
0.68
79%
1930s 128 99
0.45
56%
1940s 132 199
0.88
60%
1950s 197 336
1.00
74%
1960s 356 495
0.81
78%
1970s 274 499
1.06
77%
1980s 205 455
1.30
77%
1990s 185 439
1.39
80%
2000s 90 238
1.54
81%
2010s 66 101
0.89
74%
2020s 71 68
0.56
51%

The index compares each decade's share of single-film picks with its share of the collection. Box sets are excluded from it: taking the Bergman set is a decision about Bergman, not about the 1950s.

By country

Reached for most

CountryShelfIndex
Soviet Union 16
2.01
Poland 11
1.59
Mexico 16
1.57
United States 582
1.50
Spain 15
1.44

Walked past most

CountryShelfIndex
Hong Kong 38
0.20
Cuba 18
0.29
Iran 30
0.31
Sweden 66
0.35
India 18
0.36
Every country with at least 10 films
Country In collection Picks Reached for Films reached
United States 582 1497
1.50
81%
France 277 314
0.66
69%
Japan 216 166
0.45
62%
United Kingdom 142 274
1.13
71%
Italy 88 180
1.20
76%
Sweden 66 39
0.35
83%
Germany 40 56
0.82
60%
Hong Kong 38 13
0.20
79%
Iran 30 16
0.31
37%
Canada 19 38
1.17
79%
Cuba 18 9
0.29
17%
India 18 11
0.36
56%
Czechoslovakia 17 26
0.90
94%
Mexico 16 43
1.57
94%
Soviet Union 16 55
2.01
75%
Spain 15 37
1.44
80%
Denmark 14 23
0.96
100%
Belgium 11 12
0.64
91%
Poland 11 30
1.59
64%

Criterion's listing gives one country per film, so a co-production counts only under whichever country Criterion credits first. Countries with fewer than 10 films in the collection are left out.

By trade

Criterion says what each guest does for a living, and it turns out to predict the one thing you would expect it to least: whether they walk out with a film in another language. Guests who direct and do not act reach for subtitles 19 points more often than guests who act and do not direct. The guests who do both sit between them, which is the part that makes it an ordering rather than a coincidence.

Share of picks in a language other than English, by trade
acts, does not direct 29%
acts and directs 37%
directs, does not act 48%
single-film picks films reached, box sets opened
Table view
Share of picks in a language other than English, by trade
single-film picks 95% interval Picks films reached, box sets opened
acts, does not direct 29% 26% to 32% 864 45%
acts and directs 37% 32% to 43% 313 59%
directs, does not act 48% 44% to 51% 760 68%
the shelf 56% · · ·

Two things worth reading off the second lens. Everyone reaches for subtitles less often than the shelf offers when they choose a single film, and directors overtake the shelf once box sets are opened. The box sets are where the subtitles arrive.

The same share, year by year
acts, does not direct
22%
acts and directs
38%
directs, does not act
33%

Every panel is drawn to the same scale, topping out at 80%. The rule across all three is the shelf, 55.6%.

Table view
The same share, year by year
Filmed acts, does not directacts and directsdirects, does not act
2022 33% of 36 · 35% of 40
2023 46% of 85 46% of 24 50% of 156
2024 30% of 205 33% of 57 49% of 163
2025 28% of 256 35% of 103 45% of 181
2026 22% of 257 38% of 86 33% of 51

Guests who act are a recent arrival: there were seven visits by directors and none by an actor in 2012, and the two are near parity now. So the pooled comparison above is also a comparison of eras, and this is the control. What survives it is the gap between the two ends: in every one of these years, guests who direct reached for subtitles more often than guests who act. The three-way ordering does not survive. The middle group is the smallest in every column and it sits a whisker under the actors in 2023 and over the directors in 2026, so read it as corroboration and not as a third result. Years need at least 25 single-film picks from both ends of the divide to earn a column, and the last one is a part-year, so its final point is the least settled figure on the chart.

Every trade, counted as many times as it applies

The three groups above are exclusive. This table is not: a guest described as an actor and a director is both, the same way a film is several genres at once. Trades are read off 307 of the guests and 129 carry no description to read.

Trade Guests Visits Picks Subtitled Box sets Median age of pick
acts 161 163 1,179 31% 11% 44 yrs
directs 153 157 1,080 45% 16% 48 yrs
writes 101 103 680 37% 16% 45 yrs
makes music 32 32 187 31% 14% 41 yrs

A trade is read from Criterion's own description of the guest and only on a solo visit, so a pair filmed together carries neither person's job. The three groups in the divide are exclusive; the table above them is not, because a guest described as an actor and a director is both.

By genre

Genres are TMDB's, over the 1720 of 1736 collection films that carry one (99%). A film carries several at once, so these shares sum past 100%.

Genre In collection Picks Reached for Films reached
Drama 1272 2355
1.05
72%
Comedy 389 783
1.14
80%
Romance 375 686
1.04
72%
Crime 252 519
1.17
69%
Thriller 213 468
1.25
72%
Documentary 158 140
0.50
68%
Action 120 41
0.19
73%
Adventure 116 116
0.57
84%
History 112 179
0.91
65%
Mystery 103 221
1.22
73%
Fantasy 97 170
1.00
79%
War 81 113
0.79
63%
Horror 77 172
1.27
81%
Music 71 106
0.85
76%
Science Fiction 71 100
0.80
73%
Western 34 70
1.17
94%
Family 21 41
1.11
76%

The canon or the new releases

A spine number is roughly release order, so low numbers are the films Criterion built its name on. Guests land almost exactly in the middle: the mean pick sits at the 49% mark, against the 50% a blindfolded guest would manage.

Spine range In collection Picks Reached for
1-267 253 669
1.13
268-533 252 444
0.76
534-798 253 593
1.00
799-1059 252 736
1.25
1060-1340 253 507
0.86

Deepest into the back catalogue

Newest taste

Over the 1263 films that carry a spine number. The other 473 are non-spine releases and are excluded rather than treated as spine zero. That excluded quarter of the collection is described here in full, because a chart silently leaving out 27% of the shelf should be able to say what it left out.

By language

The trade comparison above reads language as a yes or no. The field is not: 41 languages, and the shape inside it is sharper than the binary. Guests do not avoid subtitles in general. They under-reach for the two largest subtitled shelves Criterion has, French and Japanese, and over-reach for Spanish and Russian.

Language In collection Picks Reached for Films reached
English 763 1848
1.41
599
French 288 317
0.64
204
Japanese 216 171
0.46
134
Italian 86 183
1.24
67
Swedish 64 40
0.36
53
Spanish 51 98
1.12
32
German 46 57
0.72
30
Cantonese 32 13
0.24
24
Persian 28 13
0.27
10
Russian 19 48
1.47
14
Chinese 17 23
0.79
11
Czech 16 26
0.94
16

The index compares each language's share of single-film picks with its share of the collection. Both shares are taken over the 1719 films that carry a usable original language: TMDB's `xx` means no language, used for silent films and undetermined records, and it is treated as unknown here exactly as trades.py treats it, so neither side of the ratio can absorb missing data. Box sets are excluded from the index, as they are from every other index on this site, because taking the Varda set is a decision about Varda rather than about French. Languages with fewer than 15 films in the collection are left out. The index measures selection against the collection as it stands today, not against what was on the shelf when a given visit was filmed.

How far back

The median film chosen on its own is 46 years old, and that has not moved: across the years carrying enough picks to compare, the rank correlation between the year of a visit and the median age of its films is -0.047 with a p-value of 0.8796 over 2,000 permutations. What does move is the median year: 1961 in the first visits, 1981 in the most recent. The series keeps reaching about the same distance back, and the distance travels with the calendar.

Visit year Picks Median film year Median age Middle half of ages
2010 8 1961 49 ·
2011 34 1970 41.5 27.2 to 51.8
2012 13 1960 52 ·
2013 25 1963 50 38 to 57
2014 69 1967 47 32 to 56
2015 92 1974 41 25.8 to 51.5
2016 97 1965 51 32 to 59
2017 157 1971 46 33 to 58
2018 96 1972 46 33.8 to 56.2
2019 30 1975 44.5 27.8 to 59.5
2021 49 1974 47 35 to 65
2022 191 1975 47 32 to 63
2023 392 1975 48 32 to 60.2
2024 531 1979 45 29 to 61
2025 687 1979 46 32 to 62
2026 486 1981 45 33.2 to 62.8

Single-film picks only, and an age is the visit's year minus the film's year, because Criterion's listing carries a year rather than a release date. Quartiles are shown only for years with at least 25 picks.