Closet Picks

The crowd and the clock

What the public makes of it

A room full of filmmakers might be expected to reach past the consensus favourites. IMDb's rating is that consensus here, and TMDB fills in the films IMDb does not cover: never both for the same film, one source per film, named alongside every number below. 1705 of 1736 films carry a rating from either (1692 from IMDb, 13 falling back to TMDB), fewer than the 1727 that matched a TMDB entry at all.

Information courtesy of IMDb (https://www.imdb.com). Used with permission.

Collection average
7.26
over 1,705 rated films: 1,692 from IMDb, 13 from TMDB
Picked average
7.54
weighted by how often each is picked, over 2,945 rated pick rows: 2,923 from IMDb, 22 from TMDB
Gap
+0.28
guests land above the shelf average: 2,945 rated pick rows against 1,705 rated films, two populations and two mixes
Measured viewing
10,686h+
a floor over all 414 visits: 39 reached something with no runtime on record

Does a higher rating mean more picks

Times picked Films Mean rating IMDb / TMDB
1 244 7.33 242 / 2
2 189 7.31 188 / 1
3-4 170 7.51 170 / 0
5-9 194 7.59 193 / 1
10+ 44 7.70 43 / 1

Each band's mean is over the films in it, and the last column says how many of those ratings are IMDb's and how many fell back to TMDB.

Well picked, low rated

FilmPicksRating
Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom 11 5.8 IMDb
Beyond the Valley of the Dolls 4 6.1 IMDb
Tiny Furniture 5 6.2 IMDb
The Blob 6 6.3 IMDb
Fat Girl 7 6.4 IMDb
Shampoo 12 6.4 IMDb
Crash 6 6.4 IMDb
Jo Jo Dancer, Your Life Is Calling 5 6.4 IMDb
Antichrist 4 6.5 IMDb
Multiple Maniacs 3 6.5 IMDb
The Night Porter 6 6.6 IMDb
Things to Come 4 6.6 IMDb

Well picked, high rated

FilmPicksRating
12 Angry Men 11 9.0 IMDb
Harakiri 3 8.6 IMDb
The Silence of the Lambs 4 8.6 IMDb
Seven Samurai 10 8.6 IMDb
Parasite 6 8.5 IMDb
City Lights 10 8.5 IMDb
Modern Times 3 8.5 IMDb
WALL·E 9 8.4 IMDb
Paths of Glory 4 8.4 IMDb
Woman in the Dunes 6 8.4 IMDb
High and Low 6 8.4 IMDb
Dekalog 12 8.4 TMDB

Guests reaching lowest

GuestPicksMean IMDb / TMDB
Ben Whishaw 6 6.65 6 / 0
Karina Longworth 9 6.86 9 / 0
John Waters 5 6.92 5 / 0
Rosanna Arquette 8 6.97 8 / 0
Mary Bronstein 6 7.02 6 / 0
Atom Egoyan 5 7.06 5 / 0
Yo La Tengo 9 7.09 9 / 0
Rachel Sennott 5 7.10 5 / 0
Gregg Araki 6 7.12 6 / 0
Laurie Anderson 7 7.13 7 / 0
Billy Eichner 5 7.14 5 / 0
Guy Maddin 6 7.15 6 / 0

Guests reaching highest

GuestPicksMean IMDb / TMDB
Stellan Skarsgård 5 8.20 5 / 0
Koji Yakusho 7 8.07 7 / 0
Nicholas Hoult 7 8.06 7 / 0
Johnnie To 5 8.02 4 / 1
Hideo Kojima 8 8.01 8 / 0
Lisa Kudrow 5 8.00 5 / 0
Harris Savides 5 7.96 5 / 0
Cristian Mungiu 5 7.96 4 / 1
Amy Heckerling 7 7.94 7 / 0
Matteo Garrone 5 7.92 5 / 0
Frederick Wiseman 5 7.92 5 / 0
Lav Diaz 8 7.91 8 / 0

A guest mean is over that guest's own rated pick rows, at least 5 of them, and the last column says which source each of those ratings came from.

IMDb is the primary rating, TMDB the fallback for whatever it lacks: never averaged together for the same film, one source per film, named in rating_source. IMDb needs at least 100 votes and TMDB at least 10, over the 1705 collection films that carry a rating from either: 1692 from IMDb and 13 falling back to TMDB. The picked mean is taken over pick rows rather than films, a different population and a different mix: 2923 from IMDb and 22 falling back to TMDB over 2945 rated pick rows. Box sets are excluded: they have no rating of their own.

Hours on the shelf

What it would take to watch everything a guest reached for, box sets included. Runtimes are TMDB's, so they describe TMDB's cut rather than Criterion's edition. Box sets count as the films inside them. A television series' own total runtime is not tracked (TMDB gives one representative episode length, not a total, and episodes are not uniform), so a visit that reaches one is excluded from ranking rather than published with a guessed total. A visit is ranked only when at least 80% of what it reached has a runtime, it reached at least 4 films, and it did not reach a series, which excludes 31 of 414. The hours counted across the whole run are a floor rather than a total: they cover all 414 visits, but only the runtimes on record, and 39 visits reached something without one. Every visit's own total is published beside these rankings, with the coverage that qualifies it, so the page about one visit can say "at least" where that coverage is short. The median is taken over the visits with every runtime on record, rather than over the ranked ones, because a ranked visit's total is allowed to be a floor and a median of floors is a floor as well.

TMDB coverage for runtimes: 1715 of 1736 films (99%). A match is not a runtime, so this counts the films that have one, not the 1727 that matched. 383 of 414 visits are ranked; 31 are left out, because 0 have runtimes for too little of what they reached, 2 chose too few films to compare, and 29 reached a television series, whose own total runtime TMDB does not give.